Derivatives, One Step at a Time

Futures Basis Risk: Spot Minus Futures

Loading Java…

The gap can change before the hedge ends

The futures hedge from the previous lesson ended at a different price from the flour purchase. That gap has a name: basis. We use one convention throughout: physical spot price minus the quote of the futures contract used for hedging.

The same futures contract starts at $22. At entry, physical flour is $21. Close the hedge on the business transaction date, before the futures contract expires.

Predict the result, run the calculation, then make the requested change. Use signed numbers without units for numeric checks. Each calculation stands alone.

For decimal answers, round to two decimal places; trailing zeros are optional.

What is basis risk?

Basis = spot price of the asset being hedged − futures price of the contract used. A rise in basis is strengthening; a fall is weakening. Other markets sometimes reverse the sign convention, so always check the definition.

For a one-for-one quantity hedge, effective price = entry futures quote + closing basis. An uncertain closing basis makes the eventual effective price uncertain even when the entry quote is known.

Closing basis, with entry futures $22Effective purchase price or sale price
−$0.50 per bag$21.50 per bag
$0$22 per bag
+$1 per bag$23 per bag

A lower effective price helps a buyer; a higher one helps a seller. Convergence toward zero applies to matching deliverables at contract expiry, not automatically to a different grade, location or an earlier hedge close. We exclude fees, financing and default and assume matching quantities.

Exercise 1 — State the sign convention

At entry the physical price is $21 and the chosen futures quote is $22. Subtract in the stated order. A negative basis is a price difference, not a negative commodity price and not a measure of the whole contract’s gain.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

What is the signed entry basis per bag?

Need a hint?

Always use spot minus futures in these notebooks.

Waiting for your answer.

Exercise 2 — Calculate basis at the business date

When the bakery buys its flour, the physical price is $26 and the same futures contract is quoted at $25. The two quotes moved differently. Compute the closing basis without substituting the old entry futures quote.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

What is the closing basis per bag?

Need a hint?

Use the physical price and futures quote from the same date.

Waiting for your answer.

Exercise 3 — Measure strengthening

The basis moved from −$1 to +$1. Calculate closing minus entry basis. A move across zero still has an ordinary signed change. Strengthening does not mean that both quoted prices must rise; it describes the difference between them.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

By how many dollars per bag did the basis strengthen?

Need a hint?

Subtract the entire entry basis, including its negative sign.

Waiting for your answer.

Read the picture

With entry futures at $22, closing basis −$0.50 produces a $21.50 effective price and closing basis +$1 produces $23. Buyers and sellers prefer opposite outcomes.

The diagram shows the stated worked example. Editing a calculation does not update the picture.

Exercise 4 — Translate basis into an effective price

The entry futures quote is fixed at $22. Add the original +$1 closing basis. Then replace the closing basis with −$0.50. You are comparing two possible outcomes, not assuming either was known at entry.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

With a closing basis of −$0.50, what is the effective price per bag?

Need a hint?

Replace +1 with +(-0.5), preserving the sign.

Waiting for your answer.

Exercise 5 — Distinguish the buyer from the seller

Compare the $23 and $21.50 effective prices. Both follow the same formula, but the business objective is different. The buyer pays the effective price; the seller receives it. Evaluate the stronger basis relative to the weaker one, holding entry futures fixed.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · CHOOSE ONE

Who benefits from the higher effective price caused by the stronger closing basis?

Need a hint?

Identify the actual exposure, the contract direction and what remains uncertain.

Waiting for your answer.

Exercise 6 — Do not substitute the entry basis

Consider a different early close: spot is $24 and futures are $23.50. Calculate their gap. With entry futures still at $22, this makes effective price $22.50; the −$1 basis observed at entry is not the closing gap.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

What closing basis belongs in this scenario’s effective-price formula?

Need a hint?

Take prices from the hedge-close date, not its opening date.

Waiting for your answer.

Read the picture

A schematic matching-asset timeline has basis −$1 at entry, +$1 when the hedge closes early, and zero at futures expiry.

The diagram shows the stated worked example. Editing a calculation does not update the picture.

Exercise 7 — Check when convergence applies

If the same deliverable spot asset and futures meet at expiry, a zero basis would give a $22 effective price in our model. An earlier transaction does not inherit that zero automatically. Different grades and locations can also retain a price difference.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · CHOOSE ONE

Must basis be zero when a hedge is closed before futures expiry?

Need a hint?

Identify the actual exposure, the contract direction and what remains uncertain.

Waiting for your answer.

Remember

Basis risk is uncertainty about the closing gap, not simply the existence of a gap today. State spot minus futures before interpreting strengthening or weakening. An early close is not contract expiry.

Keyboard shortcuts

Press Esc to enter cell command mode. Then use the keys below. Press Enter to edit again.

A
In command mode: insert a Java cell above the selected cell.
B
In command mode: insert a Java cell below the selected cell.
D, D
In command mode: press D twice within one second to delete the selected cell. Runtime variables remain until kernel restart.
Z
In command mode: undo the last cell deletion.
Shift + Enter
Run code, check a quiz answer, or advance past Markdown; then select the next cell.
Tab
Move focus to the next control or cell.
Shift + Tab
Move focus to the previous control or cell.
Enter
Edit the selected cell in command mode; check an answer when a quiz input is focused, or activate a focused button.
Esc
Enter cell command mode, or close this popup when it is open.