Derivatives, One Step at a Time

Cross Hedging: Related Assets and Residual Risk

Loading Java…

A related contract is not the same ingredient

The bakery now needs 100 bags of specialty flour. The only contract in our fictional market is a standard-flour future, covering 25 bags. The two products have related prices, but they are different grades and their price changes need not match.

Specialty flour starts at $30 per bag; standard-flour futures start at $22. We begin with four long contracts, then examine what remains exposed.

Predict the result, run the calculation, then make the requested change. Use signed numbers without units for numeric checks. Each calculation stands alone.

For decimal answers, round to two decimal places; trailing zeros are optional.

What is cross hedging?

Cross hedging uses a derivative on a related asset to offset exposure in another asset. A similar name or equal bag count does not establish an effective hedge. What matters is the relationship between price changes over the hedge horizon.

Let h be futures units per physical unit. For a buyer, change in effective cost per unit = change in physical price − h × change in futures price. This is a change from the starting physical-price budget, not the final full purchase bill.

Correlation measures how changes move together; it is not a conversion factor or a promise. Correlation of price levels can be misleading. Estimates can change, and two scenarios cannot establish a reliable historical correlation.

All prices and contracts here are fictional. Bags are comparable quantity units, but grade risk remains. We exclude fees, financing and default. Later we choose h from estimated volatility and correlation rather than assuming h = 1.

Exercise 1 — Measure the actual ingredient’s change

Specialty flour rises from $30 to $35. Calculate the change per bag. Then change the ending specialty price to $36. This measures the bakery’s actual exposure, not the price change of the substitute futures.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

At a $36 specialty price, what is the increase per bag?

Need a hint?

Keep the starting specialty price at $30.

Waiting for your answer.

Exercise 2 — Measure the proxy separately

Standard-flour futures rise from $22 to $25. Compute the change in the chosen contract. The starting $8 difference between specialty flour and standard futures does not tell you how their future changes will compare.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

How many dollars per bag does the futures quote rise?

Need a hint?

Compare entry and exit quotes for the same futures contract.

Waiting for your answer.

Exercise 3 — Find the unmatched change

With h = 1, subtract the $3 futures gain per unit from the $5 physical-price increase. Then change the futures increase to $4 while keeping the physical increase at $5. A positive remainder means the effective purchase cost rose.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

With a $4 futures increase, how much purchase-cost increase remains per bag?

Need a hint?

Use 5 − 4 after making the requested change.

Waiting for your answer.

Read the picture

Specialty flour rises $5 per bag while the standard-flour future rises $3. The long proxy hedge leaves $2 per bag, or $200, of extra effective cost.

The diagram shows the stated worked example. Editing a calculation does not update the picture.

Exercise 4 — Scale the residual to the whole purchase

Return to the original $5 physical increase and $3 futures increase. Multiply each by 100 bags. Subtract to find the increase in effective total cost relative to the original $3,000 specialty-flour budget.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

How many dollars of extra effective cost remain?

Need a hint?

Multiply both price changes by the same 100-bag quantity.

Waiting for your answer.

Exercise 5 — Stress a breakdown in co-movement

Keep specialty flour at $35 but let standard-flour futures fall from $22 to $21. The long futures now lose money while the physical bill rises. Compute the extra effective cost. A relationship that helped historically need not help in every future scenario.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

What extra cost remains when the proxy futures fall to $21?

Need a hint?

Subtract the negative futures gain rather than treating it as a benefit.

Waiting for your answer.

Exercise 6 — Compare correlations under a stated model

Suppose two equally available proxies have the same price-change volatility and costs. Estimated positive correlations with specialty-flour changes are 0.90 for A and 0.40 for B. At each proxy’s minimum-variance ratio, the idealized variance reduction is correlation squared. Compare the two fractions; this is a model comparison, not a guarantee.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · CHOOSE ONE

Under these assumptions, which proxy has lower minimum residual variance?

Need a hint?

Identify the actual exposure, the contract direction and what remains uncertain.

Waiting for your answer.

Read the picture

Related grades share some market exposure but can diverge. Two example outcomes leave $200 or $600 extra cost; an estimated correlation is not a guarantee.

The diagram shows the stated worked example. Editing a calculation does not update the picture.

Exercise 7 — Keep final cost separate from its change

For the original scenario, pay $3,500 for specialty flour and subtract $300 futures P&L. The effective bill is $3,200, compared with the starting $3,000 budget. A positive futures gain can coexist with an increase in effective business cost.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · CHOOSE ONE

Does the $300 futures gain prove this cross hedge locked the original $3,000 budget?

Need a hint?

Identify the actual exposure, the contract direction and what remains uncertain.

Waiting for your answer.

Remember

Choose a proxy using price-change relationships, not similar labels or matching contract counts alone. Measure the residual on the business exposure. Cross hedging can reduce estimated risk without fixing the effective price.

Keyboard shortcuts

Press Esc to enter cell command mode. Then use the keys below. Press Enter to edit again.

A
In command mode: insert a Java cell above the selected cell.
B
In command mode: insert a Java cell below the selected cell.
D, D
In command mode: press D twice within one second to delete the selected cell. Runtime variables remain until kernel restart.
Z
In command mode: undo the last cell deletion.
Shift + Enter
Run code, check a quiz answer, or advance past Markdown; then select the next cell.
Tab
Move focus to the next control or cell.
Shift + Tab
Move focus to the previous control or cell.
Enter
Edit the selected cell in command mode; check an answer when a quiz input is focused, or activate a focused button.
Esc
Enter cell command mode, or close this popup when it is open.