Derivatives, One Step at a Time

Forward prices when the asset pays income

Loading Java…

Forward prices when the asset pays income

Buying an asset now may bring more than the asset at delivery: the owner can receive cash along the way. A forward buyer normally receives neither those earlier payments nor their reinvestment. Extend the financing ledger from the no-income asset to a precisely dated distribution, and keep the old contract’s fixed delivery price separate from a new fair quote.

Predict first, then run each standalone calculation. Make a requested edit only in the named cell: other exercises retain their own stated inputs. Enter numbers without currency symbols or units, rounded to two decimals unless the check asks for four. None of the model prices is a forecast or a trading recommendation.

How does known cash income affect a forward?

SymbolMeaning in the example
SSCurrent asset price, $100 per unit
CC and ttKnown $4 cash distribution in half a year
TTForward delivery in one year
rrConstant continuous annual financing rate, 5%
IIPresent value of distributions paid after today and before delivery
KKFixed delivery price in an existing contract, $102

The present value of the dated distributions is:

I=∑iCie−rtiI = \sum_i C_i e^{-rt_i}

Here each CiC_i is paid at time tit_i before delivery. The fair new forward is:

F=(S−I)erTF = (S-I)e^{rT}

For a current long with the same remaining dates, v=S−I−Ke−rTv = S - I - K e^{-rT}. The short has value −v-v. Distribution dates and delivery entitlements must be specified; this example pays the distribution strictly before delivery.

The owner of a financed asset receives $4 at the intermediate date. Reinvesting it to delivery reduces the debt left to cover through the sale. Equivalently, finance II only until the distribution date and use that payment to repay its short loan, while financing S−IS-I to delivery. The two loans together fund the full spot purchase SS. Do not subtract a future $4 directly from today’s $100 without discounting it.

After a distribution is paid, remove it from remaining II. Use the then-current ex-distribution spot price and remaining maturity; do not keep an old dividend subtraction as well. Unknown distributions require estimates and can leave replication risk.

Cash-and-carry sells an expensive forward against a financed owned asset. The reverse trade shorts the asset, invests proceeds and buys the forward; the stock borrower must compensate the lender for the distribution. Free, reliable short borrowing and usable proceeds are assumptions, not consequences of the formula.

Scenario and assumptions

A fictional freely tradable investment asset pays a certain $4 at t=0.5t=0.5 and delivers at T=1T=1. Use one unit, a flat 5% continuous borrowing/lending rate, no fees, default or taxes. Short-sale borrowing is available at no fee except in exercise 7, which explicitly removes it. The later ex-distribution snapshot in exercise 6 is a new valuation date; its spot price is an input, not a prediction from the first snapshot.

Exercise 1 — Discount the dated distribution

Find today’s value of the $4 paid six months from now. Its present value is smaller than $4 at a positive rate. This is II for the one-year forward, because the payment falls before delivery.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

What is the distribution’s present value per unit?

Need a hint?

Use the stated quote direction, cash-flow dates and assumptions. Keep full precision internally; round this answer to 2 decimal places.

Waiting for your answer.

Exercise 2 — Price a new forward with the distribution included

Remove the present value of the distribution from current spot, then finance the remainder to delivery. Compare the result with 100e0.05 dollars100 e^{0.05}\text{ dollars}, the no-income forward. The forward buyer’s missing cash benefit explains why the income-paying asset has a lower quote.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

What is the fair one-year delivery price?

Need a hint?

Use the stated quote direction, cash-flow dates and assumptions. Keep full precision internally; round this answer to 2 decimal places.

Waiting for your answer.

Exercise 3 — Reinvest the cash rather than count it twice

The asset owner borrows $100 initially and owes 100e0.05 dollars100 e^{0.05}\text{ dollars} at delivery. The $4 distribution grows from month six to month twelve at the same rate. Subtract that reinvested cash from the terminal debt. This second ledger must agree with the forward formula.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

What terminal debt remains after applying the reinvested distribution?

Need a hint?

Use the stated quote direction, cash-flow dates and assumptions. Keep full precision internally; round this answer to 2 decimal places.

Waiting for your answer.

Read the picture

A $100 asset financed at 5% pays $4 at six months; reinvesting the payment leaves $101.03 of debt to cover at one-year delivery.

A $100 asset financed at 5% pays $4 at six months; reinvesting the payment leaves $101.03 of debt to cover at one-year delivery.

The figure shows a fixed worked example. Editing a calculation does not update this illustration.

Exercise 4 — Trace an overpriced forward through delivery

Suppose a matching forward can be sold at $104 while the stated borrowing, asset purchase and reinvestment are executable. Borrow $100, buy one asset, reinvest its distribution, deliver the asset for $104 and repay debt. Run the original calculation, then change the offered delivery price from 104 to 102.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

After changing the forward quote to $102, what terminal surplus remains?

Need a hint?

Use the stated quote direction, cash-flow dates and assumptions. Keep full precision internally; round this answer to 2 decimal places.

Waiting for your answer.

Exercise 5 — Value an old contract without changing its promise

An existing long fixes K=102 dollarsK=102\text{ dollars}. Today’s spot, income schedule and remaining maturity are the original inputs. Subtract both the present value of income the forward buyer misses and the discounted fixed delivery payment. A new quote below KK makes this old long unfavorable.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

What is the old long’s current value per unit?

Need a hint?

Use the stated quote direction, cash-flow dates and assumptions. Keep full precision internally; round this answer to 2 decimal places.

Waiting for your answer.

Exercise 6 — Move past the distribution date

In a later, separate snapshot the distribution has just been paid. Current ex-distribution spot is $97, delivery is six months away, KK remains $102 and no more income is due. Set remaining II to zero. The observed $97 is not mechanically inferred from the earlier $100.

In [ ]:
Java
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · WRITE AN ANSWER

What is the long’s value just after the distribution in this snapshot?

Need a hint?

Use the stated quote direction, cash-flow dates and assumptions. Keep full precision internally; round this answer to 2 decimal places.

Waiting for your answer.

Read the picture

Before payment, subtract the present value of remaining income; after payment, use ex-distribution spot, remaining time and no second subtraction of that income.

Before payment, subtract the present value of remaining income; after payment, use ex-distribution spot, remaining time and no second subtraction of that income.

The figure shows a fixed worked example. Editing a calculation does not update this illustration.

Exercise 7 — Challenge a reverse cash-and-carry claim

A forward quote of $99 is below the original income-adjusted model price. The code shows the quote-minus-model gap. Now assume no asset can be borrowed for short sale. A trader with no existing asset inventory cannot simply announce the reverse replication is executable. An owner may instead compare selling current inventory and replacing it through a forward.

A price-gap scale, cash-flow timeline and asset-return loop show the hypothetical $2.03 gain; a closed gate blocks borrowing, preventing the trade from starting.

The diagram uses the fixed example inputs. Amounts are rounded for display; the calculation keeps full precision.

In [ ]:
Java

Why does the code show a minus sign but the diagram shows a profit?

The code calculates offered price minus model price:

99−101.03≈−2.0399 - 101.03 \approx -2.03

The minus sign means the $99 offer is about $2.03 below the model price. This number is a price gap, not the trade’s profit or loss.

The diagram’s hypothetical trade uses the opposite subtraction: after investing the sale proceeds and compensating the asset lender for the $4 income payment, you would have about $101.03 left at year end. Buying the replacement asset through the $99 forward would leave:

101.03−99≈+2.03101.03 - 99 \approx +2.03

Same difference, opposite subtraction order. The positive $2.03 is the hypothetical year-end profit if all the required trades can be carried out. In this exercise you cannot borrow the asset, so you cannot start that trade or lock in that profit. Both equations use rounded amounts; the code keeps full precision.

CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · CHOOSE ONE

What does the negative model gap establish under this short-sale restriction?

Need a hint?

Separate an executable cash flow from a model input, an estimate or a notional comparison.

Waiting for your answer.

Remember

Discount each remaining cash distribution at its own date, then finance the net asset cost. Cross-check with a terminal debt-and-reinvestment ledger. An old KK stays fixed; paid distributions leave II. Test the asset borrowing, distribution replacement and financing before calling a discrepancy arbitrage.

Keyboard shortcuts

Press Esc to enter cell command mode. Then use the keys below. Press Enter to edit again.

A
In command mode: insert a Java cell above the selected cell.
B
In command mode: insert a Java cell below the selected cell.
D, D
In command mode: press D twice within one second to delete the selected cell. Runtime variables remain until kernel restart.
Z
In command mode: undo the last cell deletion.
Shift + Enter
Run code, check a quiz answer, or advance past Markdown; then select the next cell.
Tab
Move focus to the next control or cell.
Shift + Tab
Move focus to the previous control or cell.
Enter
Edit the selected cell in command mode; check an answer when a quiz input is focused, or activate a focused button.
Esc
Enter cell command mode, or close this popup when it is open.